I love how we all try and work scenarios out here within our little family unit. Ever since Friday I can’t get Dean’s words to Sam out of my head. The more I think about this, the more I think why did Sam want to end it all in the first place. If these are the precious words that Dean persuades Sam with. We know in the chapel he wasn’t bothered if he wanted to live or die after repeating the cold, harsh word ‘SO’. Dean talked his bro off that ledge that night so why after this time since Sam new in his heart of hearts that Dean meant what he said?
All I can think of is that its the last thing that was on his mind when he passes out. But surely Dean’s words which save him be top in his mind. That’s the last current thing that his mind remembers, isn’t it? So why were the writers all hell bent on making us continue to think that Sam wanted out, and to basically snuff it all over again.
So in a sense Dean had to relay his feelings strongly to save his brother twice. What a round about way in which to save someone. I think those words from Dean were so strong in triggering Sam to stay that I guess it surpassed the first round. Did Sam think if there ain’t no you mean don’t leave me all alone bro, I don’t want you to go, I want you to stay and fight. Selfish or not it did the trick and Dean could relax knowing that he had won the day again and there was a you and me as there always will be.
I also couldn’t understand Bobbies words as I felt he would have been one to have saved Sam and told him to kick his ass into gear and stop pussy footin’ about and get on with it. And don’t be such a whooz, not moaning and whinging to Dean what on earth are you doing tell him crap like that. I don’t no, it just didn’t feel like something Bobby would come out and say. He wouldn’t want Sam all defeatist, as that’s not how the Winchesters work. Its the complete opposite. So why did they use Bobby as the negative approach in Sam saying NO’ and leaving this world behind.
So how do you think Sam’s plight went down, did it ring true to you and the for’s and against’s panned out or something felt off. Was Sam thinking of Dean when he asked Death to make sure he’s dead and cannot be bought back. If this was Sam’s finale would this have worked for you, if he had said ‘yes’ to his reaper and gone on his merry way. Would Dean most importantly have accepted the inevitable, and allowed his brother to stay dead this time?
Edit: Just to let you all know I have added a review of episode 1 on Supernaturally Devoted if you fancy reading some more of my work. My sister blog is moving along nicely now and we have a few new authors. We each have our own area of character we follow through out the seasons. Each author brings their own style, a must for any fan.